Does Your YouTube Subscriber Count Really Matter?

YouTube's subscriber count is less relevant today than it once was. Engagement metrics like views, watch time, and interactions are now more critical for channel growth and monetization.

< Back to blog

In the early days of YouTube, the subscriber count was a prime indicator of a channel’s success. However, in today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, this metric has quickly become an outdated relic. The rise of short-form content has definitely transformed how creators grow their audiences, making it easier than ever to gain subscribers. But has the YouTube subscriber count lost its relevance? 

Let’s delve into the current state of YouTube metrics and what really matters for channel growth and success.

Understanding Subscriber Count

A subscriber count reflects the number of people who have chosen to follow your channel and receive notifications about your new content. Traditionally, it has been seen as a measure of popularity and potential reach. However, the reality is more nuanced, especially with the advent of short-form content.

Take, for example, Jacob Trahan (JayseSmacks on YouTube). It took him two years to gain 70,000 subscribers on YouTube. Then, he started posting shorts, and his channel experienced exponential growth, reaching 900,000 subscribers in just eight months. For creators like Trahan, short content has lowered the barrier to entry on YouTube. 

But this raises a critical question: With short-form video making it easier than ever to gain subscribers, has the YouTube subscriber count lost its relevance?

YouTube’s algorithm prioritizes content that keeps viewers engaged on the platform for longer periods. Engagement metrics such as views, watch time, likes, comments, and shares play a crucial role in determining which videos get promoted. While having a high subscriber count can help your videos gain initial traction, it’s the engagement metrics that truly matter.

Short-form videos, which are designed for quick consumption, often lead to high subscriber counts but may not necessarily result in deep engagement. As YouTube strategist Muaaz Shakeel puts it,

"Having subscribers is cool, but it doesn't matter if they don't care about you as a person. Especially in the world of short-form content, where your viewers are one swipe away from moving onto someone else."

Monetization and Income

When it comes to monetizing your YouTube channel, subscriber count is less critical than you might think. YouTube’s Partner Program requires a minimum of 1,000 subscribers and 4,000 watch hours in the past 12 months to start monetizing through ads. However, the actual income generated from ads is more closely tied to the number of views and watch time rather than the number of subscribers.

Short-form content can boost subscriber numbers quickly, but it doesn’t always translate to increased watch time or viewer engagement, which are more important for monetization. Additionally, many YouTubers earn significant income through sponsorships, merchandise sales, and affiliate marketing. For these income streams, engagement and niche influence are often more important than subscriber count. Brands prefer working with creators who have a highly engaged audience that trusts their recommendations, even if the subscriber count isn’t in the millions.

Community and Engagement

Building a loyal and engaged community is far more valuable than merely increasing subscriber numbers. An engaged community is more likely to watch your videos in full, participate in the comments, share your content, and follow your calls to action. High engagement rates can lead to more opportunities for brand deals and sponsorships, as brands are looking for creators and influencers who can drive meaningful interaction with their audience.

The quality of your relationship with your subscribers can have a significant impact on your channel’s growth. By focusing on creating content that resonates with your audience and encourages interaction, you can build a dedicated fanbase that supports your channel over the long term.

Growth Strategies

Focusing on content quality and consistency is essential for growth on YouTube. Regularly uploading high-quality videos that provide value to your audience will help you retain subscribers and attract new ones. Additionally, optimizing your videos for search through effective SEO practices can help increase visibility and attract viewers who are searching for content like yours.

Collaboration with other YouTubers is another effective growth strategy. By partnering with creators who have similar or complementary audiences, you can expose your channel to a broader audience and gain new subscribers who are likely to be interested in your content.

Networking within the YouTube community and participating in events like VidCon, VidSummit, and Open Sauce can also provide valuable opportunities for growth. Meeting other creators, industry professionals, and potential collaborators can open doors to new opportunities and help you stay up-to-date with the latest trends and best practices in content creation.

Case Studies

Looking at successful YouTube channels with varying subscriber counts can provide valuable insights into the different paths to success. For example, consider a niche channel with only 50,000 subscribers but highly engaged viewers who regularly interact with the content. This channel might receive lucrative sponsorships because brands recognize the value of its dedicated audience. 

Here are a few case studies:

Vanessa Lau | @VanessaLau on YouTube

Vanessa Lau is a YouTube creator who focuses on helping aspiring entrepreneurs and content creators grow their online presence. When her channel had around 50,000 subscribers, she had a highly engaged audience. Her practical advice, relatable content, and consistent engagement with her community contributed to her strong viewer loyalty and interaction.

Vanessa attracted sponsorships from companies that align with her audience’s interests, such as tech tools for entrepreneurs, educational platforms, and productivity apps. Her audience even trusted in her recommendations which then translated into higher conversion rates for affiliate products, significantly boosting her affiliate income. She was able to sell courses, conducted paid webinars and workshops, which were well-attended by her loyal audience, adding another income stream.

Her story underscores the importance of focusing on engagement, authenticity, and building a loyal community to achieve long-term success on the platform.

On the other hand, a channel with a million subscribers but low engagement may struggle to secure sponsorships and maintain consistent viewership. These examples highlight the importance of focusing on building a loyal and engaged community rather than merely chasing subscriber numbers.

Jenna Marbles | @JennaMarbles on YouTube

Jenna Marbles, one of the original YouTube stars, saw her channel grow to over 20 million subscribers. However, after her peak years, Jenna's engagement levels began to drop despite her large subscriber base. Viewers were watching less, commenting less, and sharing less of her videos, leading to a lower average watch time and viewer interaction. She became inconsistent in posting contributing to reduced engagement, as audiences prefer regular content updates.

Despite her large subscriber count, the decline in engagement affected Jenna’s perceived influence. Brands and new viewers were less likely to see her as a relevant and influential creator. Long-time viewers noticed the shift in content quality and consistency, leading to erosion of trust and loyalty among her audience.

Clearly, a high subscriber count does not always necessarily equate to sustained success on YouTube. Engagement is a critical factor that influences visibility, monetization, and overall influence. 

Debunking Myths

One common myth is that having a high subscriber count automatically leads to success. While it can provide some advantages, it’s not a guarantee of engagement or income. Real stories from YouTubers often reveal that success comes from a combination of factors, including content quality, engagement, consistency, and effective marketing strategies.

Another myth is that small channels can’t compete with big ones. In reality, many small channels thrive by focusing on niche topics and building strong communities around their content. These channels often have higher engagement rates and more loyal viewers than larger, more generalized channels.

So, while your YouTube subscriber count does matter to some extent, it’s not the be-all and end-all of your channel’s success. Engagement, content quality, and community building are far more critical factors in achieving long-term success on the platform. Instead of obsessing over subscriber numbers, focus on creating valuable content that resonates with your audience and encourages interaction. By doing so, you’ll build a loyal fanbase that supports your channel and helps you grow organically.

Remember, success on YouTube is a marathon, not a sprint. Stay consistent, stay engaged with your community, and continue to learn and adapt as the platform evolves. Your subscriber count will naturally grow as a result of your dedication and hard work.

Brands and creators alike should start placing more emphasis on these engagement metrics, rather than subscriber counts, to truly measure and achieve success in the era of short-form video content.

Big Money to Big Creators

From $50,000 to $1,000,000s how much money are you looking to invest in your channel?

Monthly Adsense Revenue

More posts

How Can I Repurpose My Content For YouTube?
July 17, 2024
How Can I Repurpose My Content For YouTube?

As a YouTube creator, repurposing existing content can keep your channel active without constantly creating new videos. Using different tactics you can leverage old content and re-purpose for fresh new videos.

YouTube Creator Tips: How To Make Filming Easier 
July 10, 2024
YouTube Creator Tips: How To Make Filming Easier 

Creating high-quality YouTube content is challenging. Let's dive into what tools you can use to further enhance production quality.